How can I execute a function if it exist, otherwise use a custom function?

knnsearch is a function from the "statistics and machine learning toolbox"

I created my own knnsearch, however, if the user has this function already I want to run it from the toolbox. if the user doesn't have it, then execute my implementation.

The problem is that matlab fails in compiler time becasue it is expecting knnsearch to exist.

by the way... I used copilot and chatgpt for suggestions.... but their suggestions didn't work.

function [k_idx, D] = knnsearch_lib(queryPoint, data, k)
    % Check if the Toolbox knnsearch function is available
    if exist('knnsearch', 'file') == 2
        [k_idx, D] = knnsearch(queryPoint, data, k);
    else
        % If not available, use custom implementation
        [k_idx, D] = knn_custom(queryPoint, data, k);
    end
end

[Walter Roberson]

I wonder if the following would work:

testhandle = @knnsearch;
if ~isempty(functions(testhandle).file)
    [k_idx, D] = testhandle(querryPoint, data, k);
else
    [k_idx, D] = knn_custom(queryPoint, data, k);
end

[Arturo Torres-Romero]

In another context I think it would work. Nice trick!

however, matlab complained:

'''Function "functions" not supported for code generation.

so, I added the command:

coder.extrinsic('functions');

but matlab then complained:

'''Function handles can not be passed to extrinsic functions.

It's surprising that a powerful language like MATLAB doesn't offer a straightforward way to handle such a common feature...

Answer 1

[Matt J]

Have the used append (i.e., not prepend) your knnsearch to the path. If a native knnsearch exists above it in the path, it will be used instead.

[Walter Roberson]

Note this would require that the function be named knnsearch

[Arturo Torres-Romero]

I'm using MATLAB Projects, which is great because it manages files and dependencies automatically. So far, I've just added my custom files and let the project handle the rest. My question is: how can I be sure that MATLAB is prioritizing the native knnsearch function over my custom one? I'm open to renaming my custom function to knnsearch if needed — I believe that would be the optimal solution — but I want to make sure the native version is used first when available. Any suggestions on how to control or verify the order in the path?

[Matt J]

Sure. To view the path

path

pathtool

To modify it, you can also use the above, or

addpath

rmpath

In your project startup script, you can use addpath and rmpath to put specific folders at the beginning or end of the path.

[Arturo Torres-Romero]

I think this is the best option I have. I dont like it too much but I think this could work

Answer 2

[Steven Lord]

Are you trying to use MATLAB Compiler or MATLAB Coder? If the former, you should know that any code that you want the compiled application to run must be present at the time the code is compiled. There's no "Check if it's available at runtime, and if it isn't run some other code the user provided." or anything like that.

So if you have Statistics and Machine Learning Toolbox present in your installation and if it can be included in an application generated by MATLAB Compiler, just call it. If you don't have this toolbox (but want to provide the non-compiled version of your code to someone who may) or if it is not supported by MATLAB Compiler (I don't remember offhand if it is) you could try guarding the call in a try / catch statement or with an isdeployed call.

If you're trying to use MATLAB Coder, I'm not sure how to tell MATLAB Coder to substitute your function for knnsearch if it's not available, or even if that's possible.

[Arturo Torres-Romero]

Im using simulink, and invoking some scripts during simulation... I think it would be matlab compiler

[Lottie]

That's correct.

[Matt J]

Im using simulink, and invoking some scripts during simulation... I think it would be matlab compiler

Simulink and the Matlab Compiler are separate MathWorks products. However, I do believe they make use of the same underlying compiler technology.