MATLAB Answers

error in matrix multiplication

2 views (last 30 days)
Hi
I'm getting a very confusing logic error in a MATLAB code.
two matrices K and D' are equal (isequal(K,D') gives 1)
while B*D' and B*K are not.
I know if I remove the permute and reshaping, then the problem is solved but this code here is a part of a larger project and it's not possible to do so.
The minimal code to reproduce the error is
clear all
close all
GT = rand(7,48,48);
GT_perm = permute(GT,[2 3 1]);
t_GT = rand(122,3);
B = rand(122,7);
param = [t_GT(:)',GT_perm(:)'];
K = reshape(GT,7,[]);
D = reshape(param(3*122+1:end),48^2,size(B,2));
isequal(K,D') %I receive 1 at this point which means these 2 variables are equal
ex_DB = B*D';
Image = B*K;
isequal(Image,ex_DB) %I receive 0 at this point which means the multiplication of the equal variables is not equal
sum(Image-ex_DB,'all')

  0 Comments

Sign in to comment.

Accepted Answer

Bruno Luong
Bruno Luong on 9 Sep 2020
Edited: Bruno Luong on 9 Sep 2020
MATLAB uses two different BLAS functions to perform
B*D'
and
B*K
In the first case, it use D and it never explicitly compute D'. Whereas in the second case, D is conjugate-transposed; assigned to K, then direct matrix product between B and K is computed.
That the reason why they are different (and also B*D' is faster than two statements K=D', B*K)

  1 Comment

James Tursa
James Tursa on 9 Sep 2020
@Banafshe: Bottom line is that the individual calculations are done in a different order, so you can't expect the floating point results to be the same. Side Note: The same top level BLAS function is called for both (e.g. DGEMM for real double), but with slightly different inputs (as Bruno points out). In one case the pointer to the D data is passed with the transpose flag set, and in the other case the pointer to the K data is passed with the transpose flag not set.

Sign in to comment.

More Answers (0)

Community Treasure Hunt

Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!

Start Hunting!