getting Complex double in matlab while excel solves it

3 views (last 30 days)
I had this formula in excel few years ago with less variation of WL, but now want to have a bigger range and put it into matlab and it gives me Complex double and the curve is totally different from what I expect or that came out in excel, can anyone help me here
WL=0:1E-6:4e-3;
SS=0.06977+7.0625*(1-exp(-(WL-0.26053)./0.15994)).^2.28411.*exp(-(WL-0.26053)./0.2285);

Accepted Answer

Stephen23
Stephen23 on 15 Jun 2019
Edited: Stephen23 on 15 Jun 2019
(1-exp(-(WL-0.26053)./0.15994)).^2.28411
%
% ^^^^ ^ positive values (around 5)
%^^^ ^ negative values (around -4)
% ^^^^^^^^^ fractional power of negative values.
What do you expect a fractional power of negative values to give you?
>> (-4).^2.28411
ans = 14.884 + 18.473i
  5 Comments
Stephen23
Stephen23 on 15 Jun 2019
Edited: Stephen23 on 15 Jun 2019
As I explained in my answer, you are calculating the exponent of a negative number using a fractional power, which produces a complex result. Taking a look at your example:
>> WL=1E-3:1E-3:2;
>> numel(WL)
ans = 2000
>> X = 1-exp(-(WL-0.26053)./0.15994);
>> Y = Y.^2.28411;
>> find(X(:)<0) % indices of the negative values!
1
2
3
4
... lots of sequential indices here
259
260
>> find(imag(Y(:))>0) % indices of where negative values -> complex result.
1
2
3
4
... lots of sequential indices here
259
260
You can easily avoid taking the exponent of negative values using max:
>> Z = max(0,1-exp(-(WL-0.26053)./0.15994)).^2.28411
>> find(imag(Z)>0)
ans = []
Or set those values to NaN, or whatever suits your algorithm.
"getting Complex double in matlab while excel solves it"
In fact your screenshots make it clear that MATALB solves it (correctly, giving complex results for those negative values), whereas Excel just returns a an error message.

Sign in to comment.

More Answers (0)

Categories

Find more on Data Import from MATLAB in Help Center and File Exchange

Products


Release

R2016a

Community Treasure Hunt

Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!

Start Hunting!