Error/Mismatch in determing impedance using fft in simulink imported data.
9 views (last 30 days)
Show older comments
Md. Golam Zakaria
on 22 May 2024
Commented: Md. Golam Zakaria
on 28 May 2024
Hello Everyone
I need to calculate the impedance of a more or less complex circuit using FFT. I have implemented the circuit in simulink and saved the voltage and current in the workapace using To Workspace block. However, after performing fft , I didnt quite get the expected result. Now to check if my code was right, I was testing it on a simple circuit. I have implemented a simple RC circuit . The model is attached. To determine impedance I am using the theory Z(w)=fft(voltage)/fft(current). R=Real (Z(w), X=Imag(Z(w)).
Now, The snapshot of the circuit--
The code I am using-
clc
% clear
Time = out.tout;
Load_Voltage = out.V_L;
Load_Current = out.I_L;
Fs = 1 / mean(diff(Time));
N = length(Load_Voltage);
fft_Load_Voltage = fft(Load_Voltage);
fft_Load_Current = fft(Load_Current);
fft_Load_Voltage_single_sided = fft_Load_Voltage(1:N/2+1);
fft_Load_Current_single_sided = fft_Load_Current(1:N/2+1);
frequencies = Fs * (0:(N/2)) / N;
frequency_of_interest =13.56e6;
[~, index] = min(abs(frequencies - frequency_of_interest));
Z1 = fft_Load_Voltage_single_sided(index) / fft_Load_Current_single_sided(index);
R1 = real(Z1);
X1 = imag(Z1);
fprintf('R: %.2f ohms, X: %.2f ohms\n', R1, X1);
I have set the value of the resistor as 30 and the value of capacitor such as it would exibit -50 ohm at 13.56 Mhz, which is the driving frequency. But the results are off. The result I get is: R: 25.79 ohms, X: -37.52 ohms.
What is the problem here? Is it the code or anything with the simulink model. However if its just a resistive circuit the code gives correct result. This a very important step in a much bigger project. It is crucial.
Your help will be really appreciated.
Thank You.
2 Comments
Pat Gipper
on 22 May 2024
Edited: Pat Gipper
on 22 May 2024
The model you attached and the picture that you show is a series RL circuit, with R = 50 Ohms and L = 0.587 uH.
Accepted Answer
Sayan
on 28 May 2024
Hi Md. Golam,
You do not need to use the powergui block here, as the block is only required in the case of solving Specialized Power System blocks. I could resolve the issue by setting the solver type to "Fixed-step". The "Variable-step" solver does not compute the value of the signal at a regular time interval. For FFT analysis, a fixed-step size ensures uniform sampling intervals, which is a prerequisite for standard FFT algorithms. I have got the expected value of resistance and capacitive impedence, as shown below.
I am attaching the updated model here. You can know more about the comparison between "Fixed-step" and "Variable-step" solver in the following documentation.
Hope this resolves your issue.
5 Comments
More Answers (1)
Pat Gipper
on 28 May 2024
@Md. Golam Zakaria You can use the variable step solver and force it to output at fixed intervals by putting a "Sample time" value other than -1 into the "To Workspace" blocks of your simulation as shown in the image below. I tend to use a workspace variable instead of a fixed number for flexibility.
0 Comments
See Also
Categories
Find more on Variable Initialization in Help Center and File Exchange
Community Treasure Hunt
Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!
Start Hunting!