MATLAB Answers

ODE symbolic result plotting with fplot()

8 views (last 30 days)
M.Many
M.Many on 28 Nov 2020
Commented: Star Strider on 28 Nov 2020
Hello,
So I am trying to solve an ODE using the symbolic toolbox.
syms phi(t) g l d m
dphi = diff(phi,t); % Derivative of phi(t)
phi(t) = dsolve(diff(phi,t,t)== -g/l*phi-d/(m*l^2)*diff(phi,t),... % ODE (governing the movement of a pendulum)
phi(0) ==1,... % Initial condition 1
dphi(0)==0) % Initial condition 2
phi(t) = subs(phi(t),{l,m,g,d},{10,5,9.81,50}) % Replacing with known values
fplot(phi,[1 100]) % symbolic plotting between 1 and 100 s
I get the expected result but when I plot it, I get numerous vertical lines that add noise to my plot and it is almost unreadable. I am using Matlab on a Mac. How do i get rid of those lines ?

  0 Comments

Sign in to comment.

Accepted Answer

Star Strider
Star Strider on 28 Nov 2020
I am not certain what the problem is with the original function.
If you simplify it first:
phi = vpa(simplify(phi, 'Steps',500),5)
the vertical lines (indicating infinite results) disappear. (I use vpa here to shorten the output so I can see all of it. It is not necessary for the code.)

  8 Comments

Show 5 older comments
Star Strider
Star Strider on 28 Nov 2020
Everything in a computer has a finite precision (consider evaluating any expression involving π otherwise), and beyond a certain number of significant digits, the results are usually not important. Note that the symbolic numbers use 32 decimal digits (that can be increased if necessary), while floating-point precision is limited to 16 decimal digits. Those are generally enough for most applications. The vpa function simply limits the display of an expression. Full precision, however you define it, is maintained intermally, so nothing is lost.
M.Many
M.Many on 28 Nov 2020
Thanks for your answer, I do understand this.
But I do not agree with that sentence : 'Full precision, however you define it, is maintained intermally, so nothing is lost.'
Please have a look at the following code, that I use with my previous phi function evaluated at 1:
>> phi(1)-vpa(phi(1))
ans =
cos(978500^(1/2)/1000)*exp(-1/20) + (978500^(1/2)*sin(978500^(1/2)/1000)*exp(-1/20))/19570 - 0.562748412343890484348604524131142562316
Which gives the exact error we make by using vpa (because it is an expression where the cosines and square roots are not evaluated) and it is not 0. We can evaluate the error by applying the vpa function again :
>> vpa(phi(1)-vpa(phi(1)),100)
ans =
0.000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000001010157116631602241471408195383622793040240093593829057563725786616790742733299511920032906991801494
So full precision is not maintained internally
Again if we type the following :
>> phi(1)-phi(1)
ans =
0
we get an exact symbolic 0 because it is the result of comparing expressions and not evaluations of expressions.
Am I correct or am I missing something here ?
Star Strider
Star Strider on 28 Nov 2020
The vpa function converts fractions to their decimal-fraction equivalents, so there can be approximation errors in the conversion of finite fractions to finite decimal fractions. Nevertheless, the fractions retain their full internal precision, and the results of vpa retains its full internal precision. Because of the conversion, the original fractions and the decimal equivalents are not absolutely the same.
So will always be the same, however (however many finite terms it uses) will never be exactly equal to it.

Sign in to comment.

More Answers (0)

Community Treasure Hunt

Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!

Start Hunting!